NB. With very few exceptions,
the following volumes are infinitely inferior to what Maugham wrote
about himself. But they are somewhat useful about facts and figures. In
chronological order.
Life and Letters Vol. 6, No. 33;
February 1931, ed. Desmond MacCarthy
"The Skirmishers" by Desmond MacCarthy is a powerful exploration of the parallel between Maugham and Maupassant, amusingly presented as a dialogue between a Maugham admirer (the author himself) and a Maugham detractor. A more substantial and more perceptive piece than MacCarthy's far more famous appreciation William Somerset Maugham, 'The English Maupassant' (1933). Some reflections of mine and some quotes from MacCarthy's piece can be found here.
Desmond MacCarthy, William Somerset Maugham, 'The English Maupassant', Heinemann, 1934.
[First published in Nash's Pall Mall Magazine, May 1933. Reprinted in Altogether (1934), the British edition of East and West, and in MacCarthy's Memories]
Though historical importance somewhat overrides its value as literary criticism, this is still a fine appreciation, especially considering it was first published as early as 1933. Not for nothing was Mr MacCarthy one of the very few among the critics whom Maugham regarded with great admiration. Unlike many of his colleagues, Mr MacCarthy obviously read a great deal of Maugham's works, and read them well too. The bibliography is not serious, but the illustrations (including a photo portrait of Maugham as a frontispiece) are delightful. [See the essay “The Short
Story” from the collection Points of View
(1958) for Maugham’s opinion on MacCarthy.]
Raymond
Toole Stott,
Maughamiana, the Writings of
W. Somerset Maugham, Doubleday, 1950.
I haven’t seen this precursor
of Mr Stott’s definitive bibliography (1973). For a comprehensive review of
this booklet, see here.
William
F. Smith, Fiction Techniques in the Short
Stories and Novels of William Somerset
Maugham, Master Thesis, 1952.
I have never read this one,
but do have a look at this review.
The Maugham Enigma, ed. Klaus W. Jonas
The Citadel Press, 1954.
The Citadel Press, 1954.
An indifferent collection of
book reviews, general criticism and biographical essays, a kind of greatly
inferior precursor to The Critical
Heritage (1987), eds. Anthony Curtis and John Whitehead. Of historical
interest only, especially if one wants to taste the contemporary academic
response to Maugham's work. Vastly amusing at some places. For extensive selections of quotes, see here.
Raymond
Mander and Joe Mitchenson, Theatrical Companion to Maugham,
Rockliff, 1955.
Very thorough study of Maugham's career as a playwright published with his own approval. Contains exhaustive information about probably all plays Maugham ever wrote, including unpublished ones and even translations of works of others. For every play there are dramatis personae, synopsis, quotes from contemporary reviews and Maugham's own works concerning the play in question as well as information about the time and place of its writing, publishing, productions and revivals. Contains also 196 photos from more or less all Maugham's plays ever produced. Invaluable book about a significant and important part of Maugham's literary output. For a table of contents, see here.
Klaus
Jonas, The Gentleman from Cap Ferrat,
Center for Maugham Studies, New Haven ,
Conn. , 1956.
The great scarcity and monstrous
price of this little pamphlet certainly do not live up to its importance.
Superficial and mediocre account of Maugham's life and works. Contains few
valuable excerpts from Maugham's letters and a beautifully written preface
(also in the form of letter) by Maugham himself. For several further observations of mine, see here.
Raymond
Toole Stott, The Writings of William Somerset Maugham,
Bertram Rota, 1956.
Another early version of Mr
Stott’s definitive 1973 bibliography I have never seen. Other Maugham admirers
have, however; see this review.
Raymond
Toole Stott, Supplement to the above,
Straker Bros., 1964.
Another piece of Mr Stott’s exhaustive
research into Maugham’s oeuvre. Have never seen it myself, but more tenacious explorers
of Maugham’s works have: see this review.
Christopher
Hassall, Edward Marsh, patron of the
arts: A biography,
Longmans, 1959.
The definitive biography of
one of the very few people for whom Maugham had a great respect. Contains some
of the proofs of The Summing Up
(1938), the first of Maugham's books to have its proofs corrected by Eddie
Marsh; his suggestions and Maugham's accepting/refusing them are also given
here. Otherwise there is very little about Maugham, and that's mostly
trivia.
Klaus
W. Jonas, The world of Somerset Maugham,
Peter Owen Limited, 1959.
Collection of five lengthy
essays, including two by Mr Jonas himself, which purport to be a thorough
exploration of Maugham's oeuvre. Except for a very comprehensive, if very
prejudiced, study of the novels by M. C. Kuner and a warm, sympathetic and
perceptive mixture of recollections and reflections by Glenway Wescott, not
really worth reading. The evaluation of Maugham's dramatic works by St. John
Ervine is a disgrace. For some reflections of mine, see here.
Karl
G. Pfeiffer, W. Somerset Maugham, a Candid Portrait,
W.
W. Norton, 1959.
For some disparaging remarks
about this book by Maugham himself in his letters to Klaus Jonas, see the 2009 mess of a
book W. Somerset Maugham: The Man and His Work / Leben und Werk. For a devastating
review of Mr Pfeiffer’s attempts at candour, see this link.
Richard
Cordell, Somerset Maugham: a biographical
and critical study,
Heinemann, 1962.
Interesting, well-written,
occasionally shrewd and more or less balanced critical study of Maugham's
complete works. Contains some perceptive thoughts about Maugham's public
persona and his family background, but there is little to admire in Mr
Cordell's literary analyses. Though he lacks the usual caustic aggressiveness
of the critics who write about Maugham, the author seldom has to say something
different than the obvious; some of his judgements are, to put it mildly,
ridiculous. Worth reading, but forgettable. For a more extensive review of mine, see here.
Laurence
Brander, Somerset Maugham: A Guide,
Edinburgh, Oliver & Boyd [1963].
I haven’t read this one. See
this review.
John
Brophy, Somerset Maugham, Longmans, 1964.
Writers and Their Work No. 22. Revised edition with additional bibliography.
Fairly interesting, rather
prejudiced, well written and virtually devoid of maliciousness study of
Maugham's fiction. The Bibliography is a disgrace. A longer attempt for a review of mine can be found here.
Wilmon
Menard, The Two Worlds of Somerset Maugham,
Sherbourne Press, 1965.
Well-written book by a fellow globetrotter and sincere admirer. Fascinating research into some of Maugham's most famous South Sea stories ("Rain", "The Pool") and excerpts from interviews with Maugham himself. Both, however, must be taken with a healthy dose of cynicism. Mr Menard's research remains for the most part elusively unsourced and he is apt to mix interviews with published writings, sometimes quoted word for word, sometimes dubiously rehashed. Recommended with caution! For a table of contents and several observations of mine, see here.
Robin
Maugham, Somerset and All the Maughams,
Longmans: Heinemann, 1966.
Haven’t read this one yet. But an intelligent and perceptive friend has. Do check this fine review.
Garson
Kanin, Remembering Mr. Maugham,
Atheneum, 1966.
Garson Kanin recorded verbatim numerous conversations and anecdotes
with Maugham. Most of them are fluff, but some offer insights into Maugham's
inner world which you are not likely to find anywhere else - if the author is
not Maugham himself, of course (this is deliberately repeated countless times).
Nevertheless, this is an indispensable, if lightweight, addition to the library of every serious
Maugham buff. Mr Kanin's warm and affectionate tone is unique in the Maughamian literature.
Beverley
Nichols, A Case of Human Bondage,
Secker & Warburg, 1966.
A notorious riposte to
the presumably vicious portrait of his wife which Maugham drew in his late and
still unpublished in book form memoirs Looking
Back (1962). Haven’t read it but am scared of doing so thanks to this
brilliant review. For a different point of view, see here.
M.
K. Naik, W. Somerset Maugham,
University of Oklahoma Press, 1966.
An obscure study I have never
read. Here is a great review by a shrewd critic.
Alec
Waugh, My Brother Evelyn & Other
Profiles,
Cassell, 1967.
Contains a warm and
sympathetic portrait of Maugham titled "W. S. M.: R. I. P.".
William
H. Henry, A French Bibliography of W.
Somerset Maugham,
The Bibliographical Society of the University of Virginia ,
1967.
I have never seen this rarity,
but it must be fascinating. A dear friend has written a fine review.
Ivor
Brown, W. Somerset Maugham,
International Profiles,
1970.
Short, fairly comprehensive,
rather indifferent and tediously written account of Maugham as a writer and
playwright, his life and views. Mr Brown's remark that Graham Sutherland's
famous portrait from 1949 and the photos of Maugham from the 1950s are pictures
of misery is a gross exaggeration indeed. Lavishly illustrated with great
photos; for them alone a worthy addition to the shelf 'About Maugham'. For a much better review, see
here.
Robert
Calder, W. Somerset Maugham and the Quest for Freedom,
Heinemann, 1972.
Fascinating but misguided study. Intriguing major concept, but rather contrived in some places. Heavily marred by amateurish psychology and ill-advised attacks on Maugham's stature. Valuable appendices on the real foundations of Rosie, Maugham's spy activities in Petrograd in 1917 and the characters based on him in the fiction of others.
Raymond
Toole Stott, Bibliography of the Works of W. Somerset
Maugham,
Kaye & Word, 1973.
Greatly revised and enlarged
edition over the previous one, first published in 1956. Invaluable resource
about Maugham's mammoth oeuvre despite some silly mistakes and the rather
perfunctory treatment of his collected editions, including Heinemann's The
Collected Edition and the many fascinating prefaces Maugham wrote especially
for it. For a table of contents and several observations of mine, see here.
Anthony
Curtis, The Pattern of Maugham: A
Critical Portrait,
Hamish Hamilton, 1974.
Thorough study of Maugham's
complete oeuvre written in a very exquisite style and with a great deal of
common sense that are not usually to be found in critics. Despite his obvious
affection for Maugham, Anthony Curtis never gets affected about him; his praise
is always qualified, his criticism sensible, perceptive and to the point.
Anthony
Curtis, Somerset Maugham,
Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1977.
Brief, lucid, balanced and
sensible account of Maugham's life and work. But the lots of gorgeous photos
remain the most precious part of the book. They illustrate virtually every
significant event of Maugham's life in terms of places, people and himself. For reviews, see here.
Frederic
Raphael, W. Somerset Maugham and his World,
Book Club
Associates, 1977.
Another superbly illustrated
book. Indifferent text, somewhat laboriously written and full with the usual
prejudices: too much importance attached to the homosexuality and the marriage,
the shame of Looking Back, the second-class author, a lot of pointless
speculations about the real persons behind the characters and so on and so
forth. The mixture as before. But the photographs are magnificent. For a few reflections of mine, see here.
Robin
Maugham, Conversations with Willie,
W. H. Allen, 1978.
Haven’t read this one yet.
Ted
Morgan, Maugham: A Biography,
Triad/Granada, 1981.
[Frist published, 1980.]
[Frist published, 1980.]
The most famous and closest
to definitive biography of Maugham - according to the critics. For my own part,
this is a fairly well researched book, written in gossipy and highly readable
style, that tells a lot about Maugham's life in facts in figures and nothing
whatsoever about his personality as a writer and a man. Full of the usual
prejudices and clichés; rather condescending at some places. For some thoughts from an old self of mine, see here.
Anthony Curtis, Somerset Maugham, Northcote Press, 1982.
Writers and Their Work No. 279.
Indifferent pamphlet, uncertainly oscillating between biography and criticism. Exceedingly superficial and barbed compared to Mr Curtis superlative earlier critical study and illustrated biography. Very little of Maugham's works are discussed and only the discussion of the plays is somewhat insightful. Mr Curtis appears to have been unfortunately influenced by Morgan's hatchet job. The bibliography in the end is the same as in Mr Brophy's 1964 attempt. It contains the same blatant errors.
Forrest
D. Burt, W. Somerset Maugham,
Twayne's English Authors Series, c1985.
I have never seen this
doubtless profound study. For a penetrating review by perceptive critic, see
here.
eds. Anthony Curtis
and John Whitehead, Routledge, 1987.
Collection of 150 reviews
(and few other pieces) of almost all books Maugham ever wrote. Most of these
are so trite, superficial and inane, that they are a great fun to read. Contains
an excellent introduction by the editors, summarising the critical response to
Maugham during his life, and many reviews of certain historical interest
(including the notorious ones by Wilson, Lawrence and Mansfield). For table of contents and some confused reflections of myself, see here.
Archie
K. Loss, W. Somerset Maugham,
Ungar, 1987.
Stupendous crap not
worth the paper it is printed on. Full of praise (?!) for Morgan's biography
and amazing amount of the usual nonsense about Maugham: homosexuality,
misogyny, cliché-ridden style, etc., etc. For an angry review of mine, see here.
John
Whitehead, Maugham: A Reappraisal,
Barnes and Noble, 1987.
Surprisingly good critical
study of Maugham's complete oeuvre. Not without some priggish and prudish
prejudices, certainly inferior to Anthony Curtis' superb treatment in The Pattern of Maugham (1974), but well
worth reading all the same. Apart from tedious plot descriptions, it does
contain a number of useful bits of information and insightful touches. For my of tendentious opions on this book, see here.
Robert
Calder, Willie: The Life of W. Somerset Maugham,
Heinemann, 1989.
Full-scale biography,
thoroughly researched and well-written. A great deal better than Morgan's in
terms of sympathy and analysis of Maugham's literary works. Suffers slightly
from Mr Calder's preoccupation with Maugham's search for freedom and enormously
from his obsession with Maugham's homosexuality. For a greatly prejudiced review of mine, see here.
Twayne, 1993.
Comprehensive but exceedingly
superficial survey of Maugham's short stories. Devoid of malice, to be sure,
but certainly devoid of perceptive points, too. The most valuable part of the
book is Maugham's own preface to his collected short stories East and West (1934) which is one of his
most fascinating discourses on the art of the short story and is reprinted here
in full. For comprehensive reviews, check this link.
Samuel
J. Rogal, A Companion to the Characters
in the Fiction and Drama of W. Somerset Maugham, Greenwood Press, 1996.
Am not acquainted with this
mighty reference work, but I suspect this review is better than the book
itself.
Samuel
J. Rogal, A William Somerset Maugham
Encyclopedia,
Very useful book for finding
quickly and easy a lot of interesting things about Maugham's life, the people
he knew, and the places he visited. In terms of his works, the encyclopaedia is
rather useless, however. Contains extremely long and tedious plot descriptions.
The history of publication is perfunctory and with quite a few mistakes. At
many places Mr Rogal is unwise enough to express personal opinions. For my extensive reflections on the subject, see here.
Bryan
Connon, Somerset Maugham & the Maugham Dynasty,
Sinclair-Stevenson, 1997.
Total crap! Poorly researched
and slanderous invective, trying to convince that Maugham's social duplicity
was far and away the most important part of his life. Vast neglect combined with
stupendous nonsense about some of Maugham's writings - but a lot of righteous
venom on Looking Back. Lots of interesting stuff on the other Maughams, but
also poorly researched and decidedly sensationalist. For some reflections by my annoyed self, see here.
A Bibliographical Catalogue
of the Loren and Frances Rothschild William Somerset Maugham Collection, Heritage Books, 2001.
Not at all so great as the
blurbs would lead you believe. Impressive collection, but with many important editions (important for readers that is, not for collectors) missing. Abominable treatment
of Maugham's important prefaces and simply ghastly black-and-white illustrations.
Valuable perhaps mostly for collectors; of little use for readers. For a table of contents and a few observations of mine, see here.
Jeffrey
Meyers, Somerset Maugham: A Life,
Alfred A. Knopf, 2004.
Short, yet detailed, and decently written account of Maugham's life. Despite some fine moments, overall
highly prejudiced with a great deal of nonsense from the usual kind about
Maugham: hidden homosexuality and misogyny in his works, vicious sexual life,
second rank in the history of the British literature, too much cynicism and so
on and so forth. Still, it is much to Mr. Meyers' credit that he has a positive
attitude to Maugham's notorious memoirs, a view that, to some extent at
least, is apparently shared only by Garson Kanin. For a couple of my reflections more, see here.
Klaus
Jonas, W. Somerset Maugham: The Man and
His Work / Leben und Werk,
Harrassowitz, 2009.
Mr Jonas has done a
stupendous hash out of that book. So has his publisher. Extremely badly
presented and superficially written chronology of Maugham's life and two
lectures (one in English, one in German) given by Mr Jonas a good many years
ago. Unbelievably disgraceful bibliography of Maugham's works, if it may be
called bibliography at all, and somewhat useful, yet neither comprehensive nor
annotated, bibliography of literature about Maugham. The only thing that can at
least to some extent justify the exorbitant price of that book is the
fascinating preface by Maugham himself (in the form of a letter to Klaus from
1954; reprinted from two of the earlier books by Mr Jonas) and the 66
photographs in the very end of the book among which many rare and some hitherto
unpublished may be found. For a more extensive review of mine, see here.
Selina
Hastings, The Secret Lives of Somerset Maugham,
John Murray, 2010.
[First published, 2009.]
Detailed and dull. Quite comprehensive in terms of facts and figures.
Pedestrian in terms of literary or psychological analysis. Much better balanced
than Morgan, Meyers or Calder. For a long and tedious attempt for a review of mine, see here.











No comments:
Post a Comment